Mystery polishes! We currently have 7 different options - 1 mystery from the shop and the following past PPU shades: Smorgasbord, The Holo-Gens, Here I Go! Here I Go!, Stuck-asaurus, Crikey!, and My So-Called CIA Operative. Feel free to request a color in the notes, but we can’t guarantee you’ll get it.

STELLA CHROMA polishes are big five free, cruelty free, and paraben free. That means NO Camphor, NO Dibutyl Phthalate (DBP), NO Toulene, NO Formaldehyde, NO Formaldehyde Resins, and no components are tested on animals.

Polishes are tested extensively before release. All are hand mixed in small batches at our facility. We follow specific recipes for each lacquer, but slight variations may still occur. 

Customer Reviews
4.7 Based on 12 Reviews
Write a Review

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
    Michelle A.
    United States United States
    I recommend this product
    A Delightful Surprise!

    I am very happy with the mystery polishes that I received! They are gorgeous and in true Stella Chroma style, they apply beautifully and look amazing on my nails. I definitely recommend as you'll surely enjoy whatever you may come your way.

    Sheyla G.
    United States United States
    I love a good mystery polish

    I was extremely pleased with the mystery polish that I received. The order arrived packed so beautifully too, love the attention to details.

    cindy b.
    United States United States
    Beautiful Polish!

    Beautiful Polish, great formula!

    Cris L.
    United States United States
    Absolutely worth it!

    I love the idea of mystery polishes and this was my first one, it's absolutely gorgeous! It's a great option for when you can't decide or just want a surprise. It's like buying yourself a gift!

    Terri L.
    United States United States
    Mystery Polishes

    I love the mystery polishes I received and can't wait to buy more!